I didn't mean to treat you so bad
You shouldn't take it so personal

I didn't mean to make you so sad
You just happened to be there, that's all

But, sooner or later, one of us must know
You just did what you're supposed to do

Sooner or later, one of us must know
That I really did try to get close to you

One Of Us Must Know
-Bob Dylan

She entered the room with quiet hesitation, her head slightly bowed, eyes cast down. She was wearing new glasses, and her face appeared a little fuller than usual. He had been planning this moment for some time now and was looking forward to a heated confrontation. But reality has a way of robbing events of the levels of exultation and definitiveness reached in one's imagination. In this case it was simply her underwhelming interest in his passionate feelings for her that so quickly dispelled the imagined glory of the confrontation. She possessed towards him a very thorough form of disinterest, one motivated not at all by resentment or dislike; those are always transparent and yield eventually to what lies beneath. Rather, he simply did not occur to her. She did not feel strongly about him one way or the other and when not in his immediate physical presence all thoughts of him disappeared completely from her mind. The only remedy he had discovered thus far for this tragic circumstance was to continue all the more forcefully to impress himself upon her. Having been subjected to her indifference over the past months and finding his obsessive love only growing in seeming proportion to it, he desired from her now more than ever a reaction of violent emotion and while preferring that it be love, he would settle for its flip side. He would either MAKE her love him or hate him but she would no longer be able feel indifference towards him.

He had argued with her to the limits of sanity the reasons justifying her inability to requite his feelings, putting both her and him on the spot and making a show of it in the process, making the process painfully clear. He built his case like a lawyer, brick by brick and he challenged her to find a flaw in his creation. He deserved her love if only because of the strength of his desire for it. At the same time he exposed the holes in her defense, the wall she had around her, guarding against his affections, trying to find a place through which he could slip.

She simply did not understand that they were meant for each other, perfect for each other. Only he could see her true beauty. He thought she looked like an angel, innocent, pure, and divine. He was Catholic. She protested that matters of love do not work this way: it was not founded on rationality or what necessarily should be. She was Protestant. But if not, why not, he countered, why not be the first, after all we both realize that I am right.

He had developed the curious ability to observe himself behaving in this manner and while recognizing on some level the seeming craziness of his actions he was unfortunately unable to continue on to the next step of stopping himself from acting as such. He told himself that having chosen this path he must follow it now to its logical conclusion. Perhaps this was just his rationale. If he viewed his behavior as destiny, as out of his control, as a role he must play to the end then he could dodge completely any responsibility for the insane passions he continued to indulge. He wanted her with such an all consuming desire, a desire that somehow transcended both the physical and emotional, achieving instead a synthesis divine, a perfect child containing both yet beyond the two. It hurt to look in her eyes and see nothing reflected back. It turned his stomach in knots. There was a heaviness in his chest.

And while he understood his actions towards her on many levels to be unfair that fact that she did not stop him, in his mind at least, partially justified his continuing to treat her that way. For rarely did she protest as he spent hours in her presence exploring every crevice of their interactions from all angles and rendering truths and import in the most irrelevant of exchanges. If it was a role and a show that he was playing maybe she was on some level enjoying the performance, perhaps even taking part herself. All these things he told himself, but nothing ever really changed.


William Crain, October 2002
stolen kisses